Take a spin on a Christmas cookie classic with these Chocolate Gingerbread Cut Out Cookies! With the subtle addition of cocoa to the classic gingerbread flavors, these chewy cookies will stand up to your favorite cookie cutters and are ready to decorate for your next party.

this recipe!

Gingerbread is such a classically Christmas flavor. And while you can have fantastic spins like this gingerbread cake or these ginger molasses cookies, seriously, try to think of a more iconic cookie than the gingerbread man! This version has all the same familiar spices but with just a hint of chocolate cocoa for a unique modern tradition!

Chewy Chocolate Gingerbread

The ingredients for these chewy chocolate gingerbread cookies are very similar to a traditional gingerbread. I did adjust the ginger down from my usual over the top amount to help balance out the flavor and to not overwhelm the cocoa. Ginger is a very powerful spice on its own!

Ingredients

• All-purpose flour. The flour amount has been reduced to compensate for the addition of the cocoa powder.
• All natural cocoa powder. Skip the special dark/dutch-processed varieties, the all natural version is best here.
• Baking soda. Because the molasses is acidic, it will activate the baking soda for just a light lift. The amount is minimal to keep the cut out shapes in tact!
• Ground spices. Quality ground spices are the best here. Like mentioned above, the amount of ginger is reduced from what I would typically use in a gingerbread to not overpower the cocoa.
• Unsulphured molasses. This is the classic molasses, do not use blackstrap molasses that is much more bitter.
• Dark brown sugar. Brown sugar contains molasses, and dark brown sugar contains a bit extra, so we are doubling down the molasses flavor. Using only brown sugar makes for a hearty and chewy cookie texture.
  

Making Gingerbread Cookie Dough

This gingerbread cookie dough comes together in a snap. Like most cookies, the first step is to really whip some air into the butter and sugar mixture. It’s important to not skip this step, really let the mixer do the work and whip the mixture to be light and airy.

From there, it’s adding the rest of the ingredients until just combined! Add the molasses into the butter/sugar mixture, then the egg.

Slowly incorporate the flour mixture that is sifted with the flour, cocoa, baking soda, and spices. Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate until chilled. The only is better to let the spices hydrate and let the flavors meld together!

Shaping and Baking Cut Out Cookies

The trick to great cut out gingerbread cookies is not relying on too much flour for rolling! Added lots of flour will make your cookies tough and dry.

A silicone rolling mat is a great idea because it prevents sticking. But pick up and move the dough frequently while rolling to avoid sticking without a lot of extra flour.

I also like to use a rolling guide and a straight rolling pin for the most uniform and even cookies. This will let you place a guide on either side of your dough and the rolling pin on top so you stay at the same thickness as you roll.

Baking time can be tricky because the dough is so dark already! For a chewy chocolate cookie, bake until the edges are set to the touch, the cookies will continue to bake after removing from the oven.

Decorating Cut Out Cookies

Royal icing is the traditional icing for cut out cookies because you can control the consistency and the icing will set to a hard crust (so no smooshed decorations in tins!)

The trick is to adjust the amount of egg white to confectioners’ sugar to the consistency for the type of design you prefer. A very thick icing is good for skinny straight lines. A thinner icing is best for softer designs and filling in areas. It’s best to test the icing on a piece of parchment first and see how it reacts!

Below is a how different a few drops of egg white will change the consistency. The tree on the left has a much softer look compared to the tree on the right where the icing holds the shape of the piping tip.

A proper piping bag is best for intricate designs because you can cut a very, very small hole for piping. But a ziploc bag will work in a pinch!

Pro tip: If you hate how the decorations come out on the cookie, wait until the icing is completely dried and scrape it off. It will be much easier to remove than wet icing!

If you prefer colored icing, I recommend to use a gel coloring (available at craft stores and some grocery stores) instead of a liquid dropper kind. The gel coloring will mix better into the icing.

Here’s the biggest thing to remember! This is a cookie, it is something fun! Do not stress over the *perfect* decorations, enjoy the creativity and the experience, then eat the evidence!

Print